Scopus Journal Evaluation Criteria: What CSAB Actually Checks
Scopus Readiness

What Scopus CSAB Actually Checks When Evaluating a New Journal

O
Oleksandra Author
18 min read

Every year, thousands of journals apply for inclusion in Scopus. Only a third of them pass the technical requirements, and of the roughly 1,200 journals that make it to expert review, the independent CSAB board accepts only half. In other words, of every six journals that apply, roughly one makes it into Scopus.

The other five are rejected. And with the rejection comes an embargo: most often three years during which the journal cannot reapply.

The most frustrating part is that most editorial teams don’t understand, right up to the end, what exactly they will be evaluated on. The official Scopus criteria look straightforward: peer review, ISSN, regularity, an ethics policy. The editorial team ticks the boxes, submits, and a few months later receives a letter: “CSAB has advised to not accept the title for Scopus inclusion at the present time.”

Who we are and why we wrote this article. Arxivia is a platform that helps researchers find trustworthy journals and helps editorial teams prepare for Scopus and keep their indexation. Our team has been working with the editorial offices of academic journals for 5 years. We have seen journals pass evaluation on the first attempt, and we have read the rejection letters of those who were less fortunate. From this experience, we know that the official list of criteria tells only half the story.

In this article, we share the other half. If your journal is preparing to apply, this knowledge could save you years.

In this article, you will learn:
  • how Scopus indexing works and which minimum requirements a journal must meet before evaluation;
  • which 14 criteria CSAB uses to evaluate a journal and what each one means in practice;
  • the three real reasons journals are rejected, based on CSAB letters;
  • what sets apart journals accepted on the first attempt;
  • how long the review takes in different fields and what an embargo after rejection means for you.

Scopus indexing requirements: what’s checked before evaluation

Most editorial teams picture the Scopus evaluation as an exam before a committee. In reality, there is a gatekeeper before the exam. Before a single expert from the Content Selection & Advisory Board (CSAB) sees your application, Elsevier checks the journal against a short list of basic requirements. There is no “partly” or “almost” here: either the journal meets all the requirements, or the application goes no further.

Your journal must:
  • publish peer-reviewed articles and have a publicly available description of its peer review process;
  • have an ISSN registered with the ISSN International Centre;
  • publish regularly, in line with its stated frequency;
  • have English titles and abstracts for all articles;
  • present reference lists in Roman script;
  • have a public statement on publication ethics and malpractice.

The list looks simple, and that is exactly why it gets underestimated. Some applications are filtered out here for trivial reasons: the peer review policy “exists somewhere” but can’t be found on the website, or the ethics statement is a single generic paragraph copied from another journal.

Scopus readiness check
Not sure your journal clears this basic filter?
Scan your journal’s website against the Scopus minimum requirements. It takes two minutes, and a missing policy page is the easiest rejection to avoid.
Scan your journal’s website

Scopus journal evaluation criteria, explained

Cleared the basic filter? Now your journal lands on an expert’s desk. It is evaluated against 14 criteria grouped into five categories. On the Elsevier website, each criterion takes up a single line, but behind each line is a specific question the reviewer asks while leafing through your journal. Let’s go through those questions.

Journal policy

The first thing the reviewer wants to understand: why does this journal exist?Officially, this category covers a convincing editorial policy, the type of peer review, and the geographical diversity of editors and authors. In practice, clearly stated aims and scope are not a formality for the website, but the first thing the reviewer uses to decide whether the journal has a place of its own in the field. The geography of the editorial board and authors answers the second question: is this an international publication or a single institution’s collection of papers?

Quality of content

A website can be polished in a week. An archive of articles cannot. That is why, sooner or later, the reviewer opens your issues.

Here they assess the contribution to the field, the clarity of abstracts, how well the articles fit the stated scope, and readability. The reviewer checks whether the abstract really explains what was done and what was found, whether the articles match the journal’s scope, and whether a few weak papers drag the whole issue down. Uneven quality is visible from the very first issue.

Journal standing

Two lines in the official list that, in practice, carry more weight than the other twelve combined.

Those two lines are the citedness of the journal’s articles in Scopus and the standing of its editors. Below, using real rejection letters, we will show why they matter most.

Publishing regularity

The simplest criterion, and at the same time one that trips up even strong journals.

Officially, it reads as “no delays or interruptions in the publication schedule.” If a journal states four issues a year but published three last year, and late at that, the board will notice. For the reviewer, regularity is a signal that the journal is backed by a stable team rather than the enthusiasm of a single person.

Online availability

The reviewer won’t visit your editorial office. Your website is the editorial office they see.

This category covers whether the full content is available online, whether there is an English-language homepage, and how good the website is. Within a few clicks, the reviewer should find the editorial board with affiliations, the policies, the archive and the journal’s scope. If they have to hunt for information, the conclusion will not be in your favor.

Why journals get rejected: what the official criteria don’t tell you

The official criteria tell you what is evaluated. But they don’t tell you what decides the outcome. To understand that, we did something guides don’t do: we took real CSAB rejection letters received by journals we have worked with and compared them with each other.

The picture turned out to be unexpected: none of the journals failed on the formal requirements. The abstracts were in acceptable English, peer review was documented, the websites were in order. Some letters even opened with praise along the lines of “the journal is well organised.” Then came the rejection.

Here is what actually stopped these journals.

1. The journal isn’t cited in Scopus

If you remember only one thing from this article, let it be this section.

This reason appeared in five of the six letters, more often than any other. In the official list, “citedness in Scopus” is one criterion out of fourteen. In practice, it is filter number one. The board can see within seconds whether journals already in Scopus cite your articles. If they don’t, all your other strengths are discounted. One reviewer put it plainly: if only its own editorial board cites a journal, how can anyone be sure it serves an international audience?

Important: citations in local, non-indexed publications don’t count here. Only one thing matters: whether your articles appear in the reference lists of journals that are already in Scopus. You should know this number before you apply, not after a rejection.

2. Authors from one place

A journal can publish good articles and still look like a regional publication to the board.

Four of the six letters pointed to authorship. The wording varies (“attract a more diverse authorship,” “seek high-impact authors from countries beyond the current sources of authorship”), but the substance is the same. A journal whose authors come mostly from one country or one network is seen by the board as local, even if individual articles are strong.

The same applies to the editorial board. Reviewers check whether board members come from different countries, whether they have Scopus profiles, and whether they cite the journal themselves. An editorial board that exists only as a list of names on a website is a weakness, not a strength.

3. The journal has no identity

This reason came up less often, but where it did, reviewers wrote about it in the most detail.

One journal covered economics, finance, marketing, entrepreneurship and a dozen branches of law. The reviewer concluded that the journal lacked any definite identity. Another letter warned of the danger of becoming “a journal of everything.” Such breadth also raises a practical question: how do you ensure expert peer review across twenty unrelated fields?

Identity has a second side. It shows in a phrase CSAB uses all the time: “Many good international journals already cover this subject area.” There is no such criterion in the official list, yet it appeared in four of the six letters, including the letter to a journal with a narrow, focused title. So a narrow scope is not enough. The board wants to understand what your journal adds to what already exists.

A paradox worth knowing

An attentive reader of rejection letters will notice that the advice in them seems contradictory.

One letter advises a journal to “expand the range of research topics,” while another criticizes an overly broad scope. In fact, there is no contradiction. What needs to broaden is the international relevance of the questions your articles address, not the number of fields the journal covers.

How to decode a rejection letter

CSAB letters are written in template phrases, and behind each one is a very specific diagnosis.

Phrase in the letter What it actually means
“The journal does not publish enough good articles each year” There are too few strong articles relative to the total volume, and the weak ones drag the journal down
“Citation levels in reputable Scopus-indexed journals are low” We checked: hardly anyone cites you
“Attract a more diverse authorship” Too many authors from one country
“The journal lacks a definite identity” The scope is too broad
“The journal marginally fulfills the criteria” You are on the borderline, and the borderline means “no”

The last line is especially important. One journal received the conclusion that it “marginally fulfills the criteria” for inclusion. The result: rejection. Being “almost ready” is not enough.

What the journals accepted on the first attempt had in common

If rejections share common causes, so do successes.

The journals we have seen pass on their first attempt were not necessarily the largest or the oldest. They had three things in common.

A narrow, defensible niche

They didn’t try to cover an entire discipline; they occupied a specific corner of it. So specific that the board couldn’t name five well-known journals already doing the same thing.

Citations already in place

Before applying, their articles were already being cited by Scopus journals. They didn’t ask the board to take their quality on trust; they could show the evidence.

The right geography

From years of working with applications, we see that Scopus pursues two coverage goals at once: regions and subject areas that are underrepresented in the database. Journals that fill a blank spot on one of these maps, and especially on both, enter review with a real advantage. It is the same logic behind the verdict “many good journals already cover this area,” except this time it works in your favor.

None of these advantages can be gained quickly. But all three can be built deliberately, and that is why the timing of your submission matters as much as your preparation.

How long does Scopus review take?

Once they have submitted an application, editorial teams usually start counting the days. And they often count toward the wrong number, because they rely on someone else’s experience. The Scopus review period is not fixed: it depends on the field your journal works in.

The process itself has five stages. You submit an application through the Scopus Title Evaluation Platform and receive a tracking number. Elsevier checks the journal against the minimum requirements and enriches the application with additional data. It then goes to the relevant Subject Chair at CSAB, who evaluates the journal and makes the decision.

The board’s workload is unevenly distributed. According to Elsevier itself, the number of applications varies greatly by field: from just a few in chemistry to several hundred in the social sciences. In practice, this produces two very different scenarios:

3–6 months in fields such as medicine, engineering and technical sciences. Scopus has the most journals in these areas, so the board has a large pool of subject reviewers.

10–14 months in fields such as education, philology and economics, where there are fewer reviewers and applications wait longer in the queue.

A separate note on economics: it is both “slow” in terms of timelines and “crowded” in terms of the number of journals. For economics journals, this is a double risk, so before applying they should be especially confident that the niche is genuinely open.

The real cost of rejection: the embargo

The most expensive part of a rejection is not the rejection itself, but what comes after it.Along with the decision, you receive a date before which you cannot reapply. In our experience, the most common embargo is three years. One year is granted rarely, and usually to journals that came close to success: strong publications with one or two fixable gaps. Journals the board considers far from ready can receive five years.

Three years is a long time for a journal. Authors who need Scopus publications go elsewhere, and the journal can lose the momentum it took years to build. This is the strongest argument for applying only when you are truly ready: a premature application doesn’t just fail, it locks you out for years.

Key takeaways: how to get your journal indexed in Scopus

The road to Scopus starts not with submitting an application, but with an honest look at your own journal. Here is what to take away from this article.

Minimum requirements are an entry ticket, not a guarantee. The journals we saw among the rejections passed the formal check without problems. It is necessary, but that is not where the decision is made.

Three things decide: citations, authorship and identity. The board wants to see that the journal is cited in Scopus, that authors from different countries write for it, and that it has a clear place in its field that doesn’t duplicate existing publications.

Time works both for you and against you. Review can take up to a year, and a rejection most often closes the door for three years. So the time to apply is not when the journal is “almost ready,” but when you can show the board evidence of readiness.

The good news is that all these factors can be worked on. Citations can be grown, authorship can be broadened, the scope can be focused. Journals that do this deliberately and before applying, rather than after a rejection, have a real chance of passing evaluation on the first attempt.

FAQ

How does Scopus indexing work?

The editorial team submits an application through the Scopus Title Evaluation Platform. Elsevier checks the journal against the minimum requirements, and if it meets them, a CSAB expert evaluates the application against 14 criteria. If approved, new issues of the journal start being added to the Scopus database. If rejected, the journal receives an embargo on reapplying.

What are the minimum requirements for Scopus?

Peer review with a public description of the process, an ISSN registered with the ISSN International Centre, regular publication, English titles and abstracts, reference lists in Roman script, and a public publication ethics statement. A journal must meet all six; otherwise, the application will not be passed on for expert evaluation.

Who evaluates journals for Scopus?

The Content Selection & Advisory Board (CSAB), an independent international group of scientists, librarians and editors, each responsible for their own subject area. Elsevier checks the minimum requirements, and CSAB experts make the inclusion decision.

How long does Scopus evaluation take?

It depends on the field: about 3–6 months in medicine and technical sciences, where there are many reviewers, and 10–14 months in education, philology, economics and other fields with a smaller pool of experts.

What should a journal do after a Scopus rejection?

Treat the CSAB comments as a to-do list, not a verdict. Use the embargo period to fix what the reviewers flagged, starting with citations and authorship, as they take the longest to change. If you need a step-by-step plan with timelines, our Roadmap is built exactly for this.

O
Oleksandra
Author
Share LinkedIn WhatsApp X
Ask Arxi